Love For MathCreative Math Education

DIY Challenge 3: 10 bars!

How many times will you need to use the weighing scale?

What students worked out7

  • Student 4

    We need 2 or 3 weighings to do this. First we weigh ingots 12345 and 678910. If 678910 ingots are heavier, we weigh ingotsa 67 and 89. If both weigh the same, 10 is the real gold bar. If 67 is heavier than 89, we weigh 6 and 7. If 6 is heavier than 7, 6 is the real ingot.

    If my answer is confusing, I can explain in the next class.

    • Student 2

      it kinda is

  • Student 7

    WE CAN DO IT IN THREE WHEIGHINGS

  • Student 2

    first, we weigh 1,2,3,4,5 v.s 6,7,8,9,10
    if 1,2,3,4,5 is heavier then we weigh
    1,2 v.s 3,4
    if one side is heavier eg:1,2
    then we weigh 1 v.s 2
    if they are equal then the answer is 5

  • Student 1

    Basically we first weigh 1,2,3,4,5vs6,7,8,9,10 for example 12345 are heavier we measure 1,3vs2,4 if equal then 5 is on side heavier the measure those to e.g 1,3 are heavier we do 1vs3.

    • Student 1

      🙁

  • Student 3

    for 10 bars minimum 3 weighing required

    group 10 bars into 4 groups
    123,456,78,9and10

    1. 123vs456
    2. 78vs9 and 10
    3. weigh group separately which is heavier

    so minimum 3 weighing required without luck
    same strategy can work for even 11 and 12 bars